3 responses to “Alien Nation remake from Sci Fi”

  1. Lexie

    I remember the movie–James Caan! But I remember the show more, its a favorite of me and my father’s. Actually we bought the boxset that came out and did a marathon of it no more then 6 months ago. Plus of course the 5 TV movies.

    If you judge the show against the movie then it’ll come up wanting (but that’s the way of such things) b/c the movie was definitely less about proving a statement or making a statement then it was about aliens, humans and the fun that can happen because of it. The show slowly went from being a pretty fun take on the whole buddy cop dynamic to using the Newcomers as templates to discuss racial issues, religious issues, political issues…pretty much you name it and the Newcomers became the vehicle for the writers to talk about it. Sometimes it worked out well…other times it was a sore try to the patience. The TV Movies messed it up more then the show.

    Then also they began to sort of ‘sanitize’ the Newcomers. First with how they looked (in the movie they were much more thuggish looking. the show had them look like bald humans with spots on their heads pretty much), then they made George want to be so ‘human’ that it put him at odds with his family more often then not. Though his family, with the great exception of his Father and the lackluster exception of his son, pretty much followed his lead. I liked the show best when it dispensed with the veiled social commentary and gave us glimpses at the Newcomer population–not just as trying to fit into the world, but also their history and such.

    Er…

    I’ll reserve judgment about the new show since Minear is working on it and I tend to like his work (or at least his influence). Curious they don’t mention the creator–Rockne S. O’Bannon. Is he then not having anything to do with it (I mean is he still sore over farscape or was he just not mentioned?).

  2. Carycomic

    I will probably tune in the remake out of curiosity. To see if the Newcomers have also spread to other areas of the United States. Like, say, Texas; or, the NYC boroughs of Brooklyn and Queens?

Leave a Reply