Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson – Breaking Dawn Death Scene?

January 3, 2011 · by Marty Shaw · in Movies

Twilight: Breaking Dawn is getting closer and Twilight fever is building once again. This means that plot leaks, both true and false, are going to be bouncing all over the web.

Celebuzz has stumbled across one of these rumors already, and it is a big one. Is there any truth to it? No way to know for sure, but we’ll let you know if we find out.

SPOILER ALERT – If you haven’t read the books or it’s been so long that you forgot how the story ends, you might not want to proceed any further.

An ‘insider’ has claimed to have read the script for Breaking Dawn and says the movie takes a slightly different, and bloodier, path than the one in the book, which has the Cullen’s diplomatically resolving the problems they have with the Volturi regarding the half-human/half-vampire nature of Edward and Bella’s daughter, Renesmee.

According to this unnamed source, Bella and Edward meet a gruesome death at the hands of the Volturi in the scenes that lead up to the end of the film.

The rumor in the ‘insider’s’ own words:

“Alice touches that head [Volturi] guy. When she touches the [Volturi] guy he ’sees’ what will happen if he continues his course. So, the first person whose head comes off is Carlisle. In the vision. Then everything goes to sh-t and all kinds of dying happens. And Bella and Edward kill Aro. Bella and Edward, they die too. All these other people die, too. Jane and her brother. Lots of deaths on both sides. Then the [Volturi] guy snaps out of it, says he’s sorry. Everybody makes up and lives happily ever after.”

What do you think about this unconfirmed information? On one hand, it provides quite a bit more action than the conclusion of the book and movies are usually all about action. On the other hand, I see some serious rebelling coming from die-hard Twilight fans. Such a drastic change in the story could make Breaking Dawn the worst movie of the saga, leading to a quick death at the box office.

Tags: Kristen Stewart, Robert Pattinson, Twilight, Twilight: Breaking Dawn

Karen

I do hope it’s just a rumor. But remembering New Moon, there wasn’t a fight scene either in the book when Edward, Bella and Alice met with Aro and the rest of the Volturi. But it worked well in the movie. I do wish they will not go far off from the book.
kate

If this is true no true fan of the series will go to see the movie because it would mean the whole point of the series is, wow—pointless!!!
Jazz

I hope that there is a fight scene. It’d be nice to see Kristen as a vampire and kicking some ass…before she dies that is, but it’s just a vision. I think it would be cool to see her as the tough girl who helps her family out instead of the one always protected.
Heather

Wow, I do not believe this, I mean I think there will be a fight scene, but bella and edward are not going to die. I just have a feeling or as Kate said, it will be POINTLESS!

nantochan

you should read the article carefully and see again what the inside guy said, I insist. it was in Aro’s vision (by touching Alice’s hand) that the fight will happen and people will die, then he realised and decided to stop. the action scene is just to feed of the audience, basically. no big change in plot.

Ash.

I’d like a change in the ending it’ll be exciting to see how everyones powers and strengths go about in combat. We know what happens reading it. But it’ll be a great change to the ending and might put me at rest. Even though I still want more books.
cheyenne

Breaking Dawn,

Hmm well there always has to be a fight scene! No doubting that but they also need to show what bella feels and edward. When she finds out she pregnant. The boulder of bella and emmett. They need to show the bloody scene of renesme and how different she is. but yeah the whole fight scene in aro head, its not what i expected but… cool! jus make sure you stick to the book!!! I hate when they cut off the good parts. G2G late-a!!! <3
http://www.google.com nikki reed

That is completeliy untrue im in the movie i play Roselie hale and that is a complete rumor do not belive everything you read check out my website nikki reed .com

http://myfbc.com Dannigirl

Seriously? not the movie part, i could’ve guessed that, but nikki reed? cause… that’d be awesome.

leyann

i’ve read the Breaking Dawn, and I’m quite satisfied how the story ends… so if the movie go on different ending.. wow.. it is such a tragedy! it’s my birthday today anyway =>
amy

well i think it would be interesting as a vision but i would be disapointed if that was the ending. i am looking forward to seeing bella show edward how she feels by letting him into her head
amy

i just want them to stay true to the book and put as much of the book in the movie as possible. i loved the third movie but it lacked a lot of the book. i just want it to fallow the book better.
http://nikanors-inn.livejournal.com/ Sasha Nova

Yes, a scene like this might play out to rile us all up and then we’ll discover it was Edward watching Alice seeing the future. Then the real outcome will be the happy ending. You have to admit the book’s ending is somewhat anti-climactic, so I’ll bet film makers are working to make it as dramatic as possible.
Paula

No please keep to the book, i have read these books many times and can’t wait for breaking dawn,
http://bscreview hannah

i think it would be awesome but only as a vision. in the book it is so boring they build and build the tension and then nothing happends this would be an interesting twist so i hope it is true but this source is not true like they say “touches the head guy” if they did get to read the script they would be a big part of the production and would not say head guy lol.
Pam

If they changed this much I would be so upset, the whole purpose is all the people coming to help the Cullens…Granted it would add action but seriously if you’ve enjoyed the books and the story it would truly ruin the ending to it all… And lose the whole use of Bella and her gift…
Nicole R

Soooo can you guys read or what? It doesn’t say that Edward and Bella die at the end in this rumored ending, it says that one of the Volturi have a VISION that that will happen if the Voluturi continue on the current course of action and then, upon seeing that it ends in massive deaths on both sides, he snaps out of the VISION and the movie ends like the book does. READ BEFORE YOU COMMENT PEOPLE!! Geez. That being said, I agree with Hannah, I think the vision would be great and add an action scene to the movie where there wasn’t one in the book, which would make the movie more exciting and maybe make up for some of the other parts that they’re sure to cut out of the movie for filiming purposes.
Sarah

Since it’s only a vision I hope it is true. I absolutely love the Twilight books, but was a little disappointed with the ending. I was hoping for a battle, even if some popular characters would end up dying.
That’s why I like the Harry Potter books a little more, Rowling’s wasn’t afraid to go their.
Jessica

I think this would be a good choice to do so. In the book they just leave with no fight scene, leaving most readers that I have talked with, with the question “why gather to fight and then not fight then just leaving?” So, I can see how much this would make sense to add this scene in the movie.
nantochan

but as what the inside guy said was quoted, he did say that the fight was only happening in Aro’s vision, and then he saw that and said sorry to prevent that to happen in real life. I think since they want to provide some action in this movie, but do not want to change the ending of the book, all they have to do (and according to this inside guy, they did) is to make the action and fighting and dying scene to be just a vision. And we all know that Alice’s vision does change from time to time based on the decision. (she saw Edward being killed by the Volturi in New Moon when his decision was still to expose himself to the humans, didn’t she?). I think it’s a clever touch.
Kelly

Guys, calm down. The insider said that this is just a vision that Alice shows Aro. It’s what will happen if Aro continues what he set out to do – executing the Cullens and their witnesses. Everything is still calm and normal when the vision ends.
Diana

Its not gonna be a happy ending if almost everyone dies in the movie… even if bella & edward dies. This fight better not happened! theres some characters that i love!

Kristen Stewart and Robert Pattinson – Breaking Dawn Death Scene?

Recent Comments